‘Bittersweet: The History of Chocolate and the Fight for Ethical Production’ – kooks stove talk

“The History of Chocolate”

The Blog – kooks stove talk / The Story of Food / The History of Chocolate

Bittersweet: The History of Chocolate and the Fight for Ethical Production

Chocolate is one of the world’s most beloved treats. However, behind the smooth texture and sweet taste lies a long history of exploitation. It also has a history of colonization and inequality. Today, ethical brands are trying to change that. Here’s the full story—past, present, and the efforts to make chocolate better for everyone.

‘Chocolate Starts as a Sacred Drink’

The story of chocolate begins not in Europe but in Mesoamerica, over 3,000 years ago. The Olmecs, and later the Maya and Aztecs, consumed chocolate as a bitter and spiced drink. It was made from crushed cacao beans, water, and chili. It was sacred—used in rituals, royal feasts, and even as currency.

The word “chocolate” likely comes from the Nahuatl word xocolatl, meaning “bitter water.”

Colonization and Commodification.

When Spanish colonizers arrived in the 16th century, they took cacao back to Europe. In Europe, sugar was added to suit European tastes. What had been a ceremonial drink became a commercial product. Demand exploded. By the 17th and 18th centuries, chocolate was big business—and its rise was fueled by the transatlantic slave trade.

Enslaved Africans were forced to work on cacao plantations, particularly in the Caribbean and South America. The system was brutal, and its legacy still echoes today.

Industrial Chocolate and the Big 5

In the 19th century, chocolate became more accessible thanks to Industrialization.

• 1828: The Dutch invented a process to press cocoa butter out of roasted beans, making powdered chocolate.
• 1847: The first modern chocolate bar was created in England.
• Late 1800s: Brands like Nestlé, Cadbury, Lindt, and Hershey emerged.

These companies turned chocolate into a mass-market product. But to keep prices low and supply high, cacao farming increasingly relied on cheap labor—often child labor.

The Dark Side: Modern Exploitation

Today, 70% of the world’s cacao comes from West Africa, especially Ivory Coast and Ghana. The region’s cacao industry is plagued by:

• Child labor: Over 1.5 million children work in hazardous conditions on cocoa farms.
• Low wages: Many farmers live in poverty, earning less than $1 a day.
• Deforestation: Cacao farming drives forest loss, threatening biodiversity.

Most of the big chocolate companies (Mars, Hershey, Nestlé, etc.) have pledged reforms—but progress is slow. Audits are weak. Enforcement is spotty. And supply chains are complex enough to hide abuse.

Fair Trade, Direct Trade, and Ethical Chocolate

In response, smaller chocolate brands and advocacy groups have pushed for change through:

• Fair Trade certification: Ensures minimum prices and ethical standards, though critics say it’s not perfect.
• Direct trade: Some brands buy straight from farmers, paying premium prices and building transparent relationships.
• Bean-to-bar: Makers control the whole process from sourcing to packaging, often with sustainability in mind.

Ethical chocolate costs more—but it pays workers fairly, supports communities, and avoids harmful labor.

Enter MrBeast: Feastables and a New Model

YouTube creator MrBeast (Jimmy Donaldson) launched Feastables in 2022 with two goals: make great-tasting chocolate and do it ethically.

Here’s what stands out about Feastables:

• No palm oil
• Organic cocoa
• Sustainably sourced cacao
• Vegan options
• Transparent sourcing

MrBeast isn’t just slapping his name on a product. He’s using his platform to raise awareness about ingredient quality, health, and supply chain ethics—while keeping prices competitive. Unlike legacy chocolate giants, Feastables was built from the start with clean, ethical production in mind.

His model is proof that ethical chocolate doesn’t have to be a niche luxury. It can be mainstream. It can be profitable. It can also be socially responsible.

Dandelion Chocolate, a San Francisco

Dandelion Chocolate, a San Francisco–based bean-to-bar chocolate maker, is renowned for its commitment to transparency in sourcing and pricing. Unlike many large-scale chocolate producers, Dandelion operates on a direct trade model. It fosters close relationships with cacao farmers and cooperatives worldwide.

Transparent Sourcing and Pricing

Dandelion publishes detailed sourcing reports that outline the origins of their cacao beans, the quantities purchased, and the prices paid. For instance, in 2023, while the average commodity price for cocoa was around $3.25 per kilogram, Dandelion paid an average of $7.86 per kilogram to their producers . This approach ensures that farmers receive compensation that reflects the quality of their beans and supports sustainable farming practices

Commitment to Ethical Practices

The company’s ethical sourcing strategy includes:

• Direct Relationships: Dandelion’s team visits farms regularly to build and maintain strong partnerships with producers.
• Premium Payments: They pay prices significantly above market rates, determined in collaboration with producers to reflect fair compensation.
• Transparency Reports: Annual reports provide insights into sourcing decisions, pricing, and the impact on farming communities.

Dandelion Chocolate sets a standard in the specialty chocolate industry. They prioritize transparency and ethical practices. This demonstrates that quality and fairness can coexist harmoniously.

For more information, visit Dandelion Chocolate’s official website.

Brands to Know

Fair Trade-Focused:

• Divine Chocolate – Co-owned by cocoa farmers in Ghana
• Theo Chocolate – Certified organic and Fair Trade
• Alter Eco – Fair Trade plus climate-friendly packaging

Direct Trade Champions:

• Dandelion Chocolate – Full transparency on sourcing and pricing
• Mast – Sources directly and publishes supply chain info
• Taza Chocolate – Uses “Direct Trade Certified” standards of its own

Final Bite

Chocolate is a joy. But it shouldn’t come at the cost of human dignity. The history of chocolate is messy, full of brilliance and brutality. Brands like MrBeast’s Feastables are helping rewrite that story—one bar at a time.